OLD PLANE CRASH SITE

Late in the morning of October 18th, 1947 a B-25 Mitchell Bomber belonging to the Royal Canadian Air Force crashed into Plewman Basin. They were heading north and clipped the nearby ridge in poor weather. The plane carried 7 crewmen and 2 passengers, both “smuggled” civilians, none of whom survived.
The B-25 Mitchell bomber was an American twin-engine, medium bomber manufactured by North American Aviation (NAA). First flown in August of 1940, the B-25 began operational service with the United States Army Air Force in 1941. The design was named in honour of Major General William “Billy” Mitchell, a pioneer of U.S. military aviation.  The B-25 first gained fame as the bomber used in the April 18, 1942, Doolittle Raid, in which 16 B-25Bs led by Lieutenant Colonel Jimmy Doolittle flying from the deck of the United States Navy aircraft carrier Hornet attacked mainland Japan.

Nearly 10,000 Mitchells were manufactured. They were used by many Allied air forces including the Americans, Brits, Aussies, and others during WWII. and served in every theatre of World War II. B-25s remained in service after the war, their use spanning four decades.
When the war was over, Canada bought 164 B-25 Mitchell bombers in the late 1940s for the Royal Canadian Air Force to use as training aircraft, light transport, and to fly special missions during the early parts of the Cold War. Some of the planes remained bombers–this was the Cold War, after all.
It was on one of these special missions that the converted B-25 crashed  The plane carried nine people: seven military personnel and two civilians (both “smuggled” aboard), a couple named Mr. and Mrs. F.M. Knight, who owned a hotel in Penticton. The plane was conducting an aerial survey and heading to Penticton to drop off the Knights. The weather was grim that day; it was the first snow of the season, the wind was howling, it was foggy, and visibility was very limited. The plane likely iced up and lost control because it lost a lot of elevation in a very short distance to end up on the floor of Plewman Basin.” But once the plane hit the floor of the basin, no one survived.
The first ski lift was still a couple of months from being ready. It was the first snow of the year and the visibility in the fog was about zero. Ken Gresley-Jones and Jim Douglas heard the plane pass so close over their heads that they hit the ground, but they saw nothing due to the fog. 
Though the peak of Old Glory was nearby and it was at the time manned by a Met Men, Bart Dudley, but he never heard a thing over the wind howling outside.

No one would see anything of this plane crash for five whole years until October 1952, when Wilf Gibbard, the man who used pack horses to haul supplies up to the Met Men of Old Glory, randomly came upon the site after spotting something shiny in the bush while hunting for grouse. There weren’t any remains left – just the odd piece of plane debris – an explosion is assumed to have erased much of the evidence. A burial marker was erected originally with a wooden cross, which has since been replaced with a metal cross.

Rating: ♦♦♦♦◊
Location:
15 km north of Rossland below Mt Plewman
Difficulty: A1 easy
Elevation Gain:
Distance:
Time: 3 hours 
Season: May to October 
Access: 2WD low clearance 
Map: 82F/

Drive: From Rossland, drive north on Hwy 3B about 15 km and look on the left for a large tree with some weathered orange flagging tape wrapped around it, located a few meters from the highway. This is the lower trail, but is almost unusable as you near the clearcut, due to a tangle of large trees that have blown down.
Finding the upper part of the trail is difficult, even for those who have been there before, but that’s the best way to go. The description is not simple: Just before the highway cam tower/logging road on the right (Murphy Ck FSR), there’s a logging road on the left (no name)
. Hike or drive up this second logging road. The wreck is about 2 km from the highway.

Trail/Route: The logging road swings around, heads south towards the long east ridge of Mt. Plewman (sometimes called Cut Block) and takes a sharp right turn away from the tree line. Look for double flagging tape and a hunter’s blind in the forest. The upper TH coordinates are 47.167285°N 117.87704°W – 5,726′ just past the blind heading left. It doesn’t look like a trail, but it is, heads directly into the forest, and follows the edge of the clearcut through a creek bed.
Once on the trail, it’s not hard to follow the “Crash Site” – coordinates: 49.167474°N 117.882076°W – 6,032′.
To get to the Igloo cabin, some pinkish flagging tape marks the trail starting just before the crash site. This trail is overgrown in many areas but has a few pink flags. The Igloo cabin coordinates are 49.164907°N 118.888348°W – 6,271′.
 

Record Mountain Gives Up Secret [Left image caption] Members of the party who visited the scene of the crash yesterday include (left to right): Wilf Gibbard who first discovery the wreckage Tuesday; Constable Charles Brown, Rossland; Constable S. A. Rammage, Nelson; and Constable P. W. Howarth, Rossland, all of the R.C.M.P. [Right image caption] Part of the landing gear can be seen in the foreground with pieces of the ill-fated plane strewn among the timber which has held its secret for the last five years. The plane was lost on October 18, 1947. -Photos by Bob Porteous, Trail Times Staff Photographer.

Record Mountain Gives Up Secret
[Left image caption] Members of the party who visited the scene of the crash yesterday include (left to right): Wilf Gibbard who first discovered the wreckage Tuesday; Constable Charles Brown, Rossland; Constable S. A. Rammage, Nelson; and Constable P. W. Howarth, Rossland, all of the R.C.M.P.
[Right image caption] Part of the landing gear can be seen in the foreground with pieces of the ill-fated plane strewn among the timber which has held its secret for the last five years. The plane was lost on October 18, 1947.
-Photos by Bob Porteous, Trail Times Staff Photographer.

Rossland Miner Article October 9 1952 Crash Found Title Crop.jpg

“As the result of a discovery made by W. R. Gibbard of this city on Tuesday afternoon, the mystery which has shrouded the disappearance of an RCAF plan for the past five years, has been cleared up and another page in RCAF records will now be completed.
Mr. Gibbard, who regularly travels the wooded trails north of the city while in the course of his duties which entail packing supplies to Old Glory, was on a hunting expedition Tuesday. When about three miles off the route which he usually follows, he spotted what proved to be the wreckage of a plane.
He immediately notified the RCMP and at 6 a.m. yesterday a search party left here to investigate the find. The party included Constable Rammage and the police dog Wolf of Nelson, Constable P. W. Howarth and Constable C.M. Brown of the Rossland RCMP detachment, W. R. Gibbard, who guided them to the scene, and Bob Porteous of the Trail Times staff…

Identify Craft
The wreckage was reported by the RCMP to cover an area of approximately half a mile long and about 100 yards wide. Only small sections were found and all of it was badly smashed but the party was able to obtain some serial numbers and identification marks from which the RCAF at Vancouver has definitely established that the wreckage is that of “the B-25 Mitchell of Reconnaissance flight which was lost October 18th, 1947…

Nine Aboard
Seven RCAF crew members and two civilians, Mr. and Mrs. Harry Knight of Penticton, were aboard the plane when it disappeared, but no signs of any bodies were found by the search party. It was the opinion of the search party members that there was an explosion at the time of the crash and it was felt no one would have survived. A few personal effects including parts of parachute packs and flight boots were found …parts of the mangled plane were partially overgrown and a small swath, apparently cut by the plane, through timbers was nearly invisible.
The scene of the crash was on a ridge extending from the first summit above Rossland to the Blueberry creek area and the altitude was about 5500 feet…
The find appears to bear out a report made by residents in the Blueberry area at the time of the crash that a flash denoting an explosion had been seen. However an intensive search was conducted at the time with no results.

THE LIST OF THOSE WHO LOST THEIR LIVES IN THE CRASH IS AS FOLLOWS:
THE CREW OF MITCHELL MK. III D-10 RCAF NO. 413 SQUADRON. (P)

PILOT FLIGHT LIEUTENANT JOHN LESLIE MACLEOD, DFC
AGE: 28
GLEN NORMAN, ONTARIO, CANADA
HONOURS AND AWARDS: DISTINGUISHED FLYING CROSS

FLYING OFFICER GEORGES YVON LEBEL, DFC
AGE: 25
CACOUNA, QUEBEC, CANADA
HONOURS AND AWARDS: DISTINGUISHED FLYING CROSS

FLYING OFFICER BENJAMIN THOMAS COOK , DFM
AGE: 28
GLENELLA, MANITOBA, CANADA
CITATION: DISTINGUISHED FLYING MEDAL

FLYING OFFICER ARTHUR GOLD ROBERTSON
AGE: 32
STONEY MOUNTAIN, MANITOBA, CANADA
CITATION: 1939-45 STAR, FRANCE AND GERMANY STAR

LEADING AIRCRAFTMAN BLISS EUGENE STRADIE BOWMAN
AGE: 24
WINCHESTER, ONTARIO
CITATION: WAR MEDAL 1939-1945

LANCE CORPORAL WILLIAM HUGH MOLYNEAUX
AGE: 24
CALGARY, ALBERTA, CANADA

CORPORAL JAMES NOAH SABOURIN
AGE: 25
OTTAWA, ONTARIO, CANADA
CITATION: 1939-1945 STAR, FRANCE & GERMANY STAR

CIVILIANS  MR. AND MRS. F.M. KNIGHT FROM PENTICTON, B.C.

In addition to the wreckage of the plane, there is a metal cross erected as a memorial to the nine victims of the crash.

The following are the lyrics to The Ghost Cat of Plewman Basin” from the CD – “Stories From Rossland”:
The winter wind blew on the ridge north of Plewman ’til rime grew so heavy; the first snow that year.
The 18th of October, 1947; the Red Mountain ski lift was almost complete.
Chick Jones and Jim Douglas cutting the first ski run, still at the top, all alone in the fog.
The old Mitchel Bomber circled three times and came roaring right overhead, lost in the fog.

Hugh Urquhart heard it in Squaw Basin, engines still roaring, but he and Dave Keffer were the last.
They must have gone right by the Old Glory Met Station. Bart Dudley was there, but he never heard a thing.
Plewman Peak passed to their right, then they turned east and crossed Record Ridge and went down in the trees.
No trace was found, though a man, name of Tjader, hunting off to the east, said he heard it explode.

In nineteen-and-fifty-two Wilf Gibbard walked over Record Ridge down into Plewman Basin.
He followed the Murphy Creek headwaters east, looking for grouse, heading for the Sheep Lake trail.
He found that Mitchel’s lonely resting place, but no trace of the nine crew and passengers aboard.
Some say for five years the animals took what was left of the bodies. Well, that may be true, but I’m not so sure.

Sometimes when the snow’s deep and the moon’s bright on Plewman a great white cat appears like a ghost in the night.
Some say he’s a lynx, but he’s much too big for that; some say he’s a cougar who’s lost his tail.
But maybe he’s the ghost of the souls of that plane wreck, wandering the ridge and the trails for 50 years.
The Ghost Cat of Plewman Basin watches over that lonely place, and for 50 years that plane and its souls have been left in peace.

And the times that I’ve seen him have made me hope
that I might find a final resting place
like the Plewman Basin Cat.

About admin

I would like to think of myself as a full time traveler. I have been retired since 2006 and in that time have traveled every winter for four to seven months. The months that I am "home", are often also spent on the road, hiking or kayaking. I hope to present a website that describes my travel along with my hiking and sea kayaking experiences.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.