Have You Listened Lately to What Trump Is Saying?
He is becoming frighteningly clear about what he wants.
In 2019, Kennedy Ndahiro, the editor of the Rwandan daily newspaper The New Times, explained to readers of The Atlantic how years of cultivated hatred had led to death on a horrifying scale.
“In Rwanda,” he wrote, “we know what can happen when political leaders and media outlets single out certain groups of people as less than human.”
Ndahiro pointed out that in 1959, Joseph Habyarimana Gitera, an influential political figure within the largest ethnic group in Rwanda, the Hutus, had openly called for the elimination of the Tutsi, the second-largest of Rwanda’s ethnic groups. Gitera referred to the Tutsi as “vermin.”
“The stigmatization and dehumanization of the Tutsi had begun,” Ndahiro wrote. It culminated in a 100-day stretch in 1994 when an estimated 1 million people were killed, the majority of whom were Tutsi. “The worst kind of hatred had been unleashed,” Ndahiro wrote. “What began with dehumanizing words ended in bloodshed.”
I thought about the events that led up to the Rwandan genocide after I heard Donald Trump, in a Veterans Day speech, refer to those he counts as his enemies as “vermin.”
“We pledge to you that we will root out the Communists, Marxists, fascists, and the radical-left thugs that live like vermin within the confines of our country—that lie and steal and cheat on elections,” Trump said toward the end of his speech in Claremont, New Hampshire. “They’ll do anything, whether legally or illegally, to destroy America and to destroy the American dream.” The former president continued, “The threat from outside forces is far less sinister, dangerous, and grave than the threat from within. Our threat is from within.”
When Trump finished his speech, the audience erupted in applause.
Trump’s comments came only a few weeks after he had been asked about immigration and the southern border in an interview with the host of a right-wing website. “Did you ever think you would see this level of American carnage?” Trump was asked.
“No. Nobody has seen anything like this,” Trump responded. “I think you could say worldwide. I think you could go to a banana republic and pick the worst one and you’re not going to see what we’re witnessing now.” The front-runner for the Republican nomination warned that immigrants pose an immediate threat. “We know they come from prisons. We know they come from mental institutions and insane asylums. We know they’re terrorists. Nobody has ever seen anything like we’re witnessing right now. It is a very sad thing for our country. It’s poisoning the blood of our country.”
In a September 20 speech in Dubuque, Iowa, Trump said, “What they’re doing to our country, they’re destroying it. It’s the blood of our country. What they’re doing is destroying our country.”
Trump’s rhetoric is a permission slip for his supporters to dehumanize others just as he does. He portrays others as existential threats, determined to destroy everything MAGA world loves about America. Trump is doing two things at once: pushing the narrative that his enemies must be defeated while dissolving the natural inhibitions most human beings have against hating and harming others. It signals to his supporters that any means to vanquish the other side is legitimate; the normal constraints that govern human interactions no longer apply.
Dehumanizers view their targets as having “a human appearance but a subhuman essence,” according to David Livingstone Smith, a philosophy professor who has written on the history and complicated psychological roots of dehumanization. “It is the dehumanizer’s nagging awareness of the other’s humanity that gives dehumanization its distinctive psychological flavor,” he writes. “Ironically, it is our inability to regard other people as nothing but animals that leads to unimaginable cruelty and destructiveness.” Dehumanized people can be turned into something worse than animals; they can be turned into monsters. They aren’t just dangerous; they are metaphysically threatening. They are not just subhuman; they are irredeemably destructive.
That is the wickedly shrewd rhetorical and psychological game that Trump is playing, and he plays it very well. Alone among American politicians, he has an intuitive sense of how to inflame detestations and resentments within his supporters while also deepening their loyalty to him, even their reverence for him.
Trump’s opponents, including the press, are “truly the enemy of the people.” He demanded that the parent company of MSNBC and NBC be investigated for “treason” over what he described as “one-side[d] and vicious coverage.” He insinuated on his social network, Truth Social, that the former chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Mark Milley, deserved to be executed for committing treason. At a Trump event in Iowa, days after that post, one Trump supporter asked why Milley wasn’t “in there before a firing squad within a month.” Another told NBC News, “Treason is treason. There’s only one cure for treason: being put to death.”
Trump has taken to mocking the violent attack on Nancy Pelosi’s husband, which left him with a fractured skull that required surgery and other serious injuries. Special Counsel Jack Smith, who has brought two indictments against the former president, is a “Trump-hating prosecutor” who is “deranged” and a “disgrace to America”—and whose wife and family “despise me much more than he does.” The former president posted the name, photo, and private Instagram account of a law clerk serving Judge Arthur Engoron, who is currently presiding over Trump’s civil fraud trial and whom Trump despises and has repeatedly attacked, describing him as “CRAZY” and “CRAZED in his hatred of me.” (Trump later deleted the Truth Social post targeting the law clerk, whom he called a “Trump Hating Clerk,” but not until after it had been widely disseminated.)
And in the first rally of his 2024 campaign, held in Waco, Texas, Trump lent his voice to a recording of the J6 Prison Choir, which is made up of men who were imprisoned for their part in the riot at the United States Capitol on January 6, 2021. The song “Justice for All” features Trump reciting the Pledge of Allegiance mixed with a rendition of the national anthem.
“Our people love those people,” Trump said at the rally, speaking of those who were jailed. “What’s happening in that prison, it’s a hellhole … These are people that shouldn’t have been there.”
The Washington Post “identified five of the roughly 15 men who are featured in the video. Four of them were charged with assaulting police, using weapons such as a crowbar, sticks and chemical spray, including against Officer Brian D. Sicknick, who died the next day.”
At the Waco rally, Trump declared, “I am your warrior. I am your justice.” He added, “For those who have been wronged and betrayed, of which there are many people out there that have been wronged and betrayed, I am your retribution.” Trump has described 2024 as “our final battle.” He means it; so do tens of millions of his supporters.
Trump’s rhetoric is clearly fascistic. These days, Trump is being “much more overt about becoming an authoritarian and transforming America into some version of autocracy,” Ruth Ben-Ghiat, a historian at NYU, told PBS NewsHour. That doesn’t mean that if Trump were elected president in 2024, America would become a fascistic state. Our institutions may be strong enough to resist him, though it’s an open question. But Trump can do many things short of imposing fascism that can do grave harm to America.
Trump, after all, has been impeached twice, indicted four times on 91 counts, and found liable for sexual abuse and defamation. Courts in New York have found that he or his companies have committed bank fraud, insurance fraud, tax fraud, and charity fraud. Trump tried to overturn the 2020 election. He was the catalyzing figure that led to a violent attack on the Capitol. And he has argued for “the termination of all rules, regulations, and articles, even those found in the Constitution.”
In our nation’s history, according to former Vice President Dick Cheney, who served in four Republican administrations and was part of the Republican leadership in the House, “there has never been an individual who is a greater threat to our republic than Donald Trump.”
That Trump would say what he’s said and done what he’s done is no surprise; he is a profoundly damaged human being, emotionally and psychologically. And he’s been entirely transparent about who he is. The most troubling aspect of this whole troubling drama has been the people in the Republican Party who, though they know better, have accommodated themselves to Trump’s corruptions time after time after time. Some cheer him on; others silently go along for the ride. A few gently criticize him and then quickly change topics. But they never leave him.
By now I know how this plays out: For most Republicans to acknowledge—to others and even to themselves—what Trump truly is and still stay loyal to him would create enormous cognitive dissonance. Their mind won’t allow them to go there; instead, they find ways to ease the inner conflict. And so they embrace conspiracy theories to support what they desperately want to believe—for example, that the election was stolen, or that the investigation into Russian ties to the 2016 Trump campaign was a “hoax,” or that Joe Biden has committed impeachable offenses. They indulge in whataboutism and catastrophism—the belief that society is on the edge of collapse—to justify their support for Trump. They have a burning psychological need to rationalize why, in this moment in history, the ends justify the means.
As one Trump supporter put it in an email to me earlier this month, “Trump is decidedly not good and decent”—but, he added, “good and decent isn’t getting us very far politically.” And: “We’ve tried good and decent. But at the ballot box, that doesn’t work. We need to try another way.”
This sentiment is one I’ve heard many times before. In 2016, during the Republican primaries, a person I had known for many years through church wrote to me. “I think we have likely slipped past the point of no return as a country and I’m desperately hoping for a leader who can turn us around. I have no hope that one of the establishment guys would do that. That, I believe, is what opens people up to Trump. He’s all the bad things you say, but what has the Republican establishment given me in the past 16 years? First and foremost: BHO,” they said, using a derogatory acronym for Barack Obama that is meant to highlight his middle name, Hussein.
If I had told this individual in 2016 what Trump would say and do over the next eight years, I’m confident he would have laughed it off, dismissing it as “Trump Derangement Syndrome”—and that he would have assured me that if Trump did do all these things, then of course he would break with him. Yet here we are. Despite Trump’s well-documented depravity, he still has a vise grip on the GOP; he carried 94 percent of the Republican vote in 2020, an increase from 2016, and he is leading his closest primary challenger nationally by more than 45 points.
White evangelical Protestants are among the Republican Party’s most loyal constituencies, and in 2020, according to the Pew Research Center, more than eight in 10 white evangelical Protestant voters who frequently attend religious services voted for Trump, as had 81 percent of those who attend less frequently. That’s an increase over 2016. Trump’s support among white evangelicals is still extremely high: 81 percent hold a favorable view of him, according to a poll taken in June—after Trump was indicted for a second time.
The evangelical movement in America has been reshaped by the sensibilities of Trump and MAGA world. For example, in one survey, nearly one-third of white evangelicals expressed support for the statement “Because things have gotten so far off track, true American patriots may have to resort to violence in order to save our country.”
It is a rather remarkable indictment of those who claim to be followers of Jesus that they would continue to show fealty to a man whose cruel ethic has always been antithetical to Jesus’s and becomes more so every day. Many of the same people who celebrate Christianity’s contributions to civilization—championing the belief that every human being has inherent rights and dignity, celebrating the teachings of the Sermon on the Mount and the parable of the Good Samaritan, and pointing to a “transcendent order of justice and hope that stands above politics,” in the words of my late friend Michael Gerson—continue to stand foursquare behind a man who uses words that echo Mein Kampf.
It doesn’t have to be this way. Taking a stand for conscience, even long after one should have, is always the right thing to do.
“When we engage in dehumanizing rhetoric and promote dehumanizing images,” the best-selling author Brené Brown has written, “we diminish our own humanity in the process.” We are called to find the face of God in everyone we meet, she says, including those with whom we most deeply disagree. “When we desecrate their divinity, we desecrate our own, and we betray our humanity.”
Far too many Christians in America are not only betraying their humanity; they are betraying the Lord they claim to love and serve,
==============================================================
TRUMP VOTERS ARE AMERICA TOO
If he wins a second term, perhaps we’ll finally dispense with the myth that “this is not who we are.”
In the last spring of the Obama administration, Michelle Obama was delivering her final commencement address as first lady, at City College of New York. Then, as now, the specter of Donald Trump had become the inescapable backdrop to everything. He’d spent the past year smashing every precept of restraint, every dignified tradition of the supposedly kindhearted nation he was seeking to lead. Obama couldn’t help but lob some barely cloaked denunciations of Trump’s wrecking-ball presidential campaign—the one that would soon be ratified with the Republican nomination. “That is not who we are,” the first lady assured the graduates. “That is not what this country stands for, no.”
The promise did not age well. Not that November, and not since.
“This is not who we are”: The would-be guardians of America’s better angels have been scolding us with this line for years. Or maybe they mean it as an affirmation. Either way, the axiom prompts a question: Who is “we” anyway? Because it sure seems like a lot of this “we” keeps voting for Trump. Today the dictum sounds more like a liberal wish than any true assessment of our national character.
In retrospect, so many of the high-minded appeals of the Obama era—“We are the ones we’ve been waiting for”; “When they go low, we go high”—feel deeply naive. Question for Michelle: What if they keep going lower and lower—and that keeps landing the lowest of the low back in the White House?
Recently, I read through some old articles and notes of mine from the campaign trail in 2015 and 2016, when Trump first cannonballed into our serene political bathtub. This was back when “we”—the out-of-touch media know-it-alls—were trying to understand Trump’s appeal. What did his supporters love so much about their noisy new savior? I dropped into a few rallies and heard the same basic idea over and over: Trump says things that no one else will say. They didn’t necessarily agree with or believe everything their candidate declared. But he spoke on their behalf.
When political elites insisted “We’re better than this!”—a close cousin of “This is not who we are”—many Trump disciples heard “We’re better than them.” Hillary Clinton ably confirmed this when she dismissed half of the Republican nominee’s supporters—at an LGBTQ fundraiser in New York—as people who held views that were “racist, sexist, homophobic, xenophobic, Islamophobic, you name it.” Whether or not she was correct, the targets of her judgment did not appreciate it. And the disdain was mutual. “He’s our murder weapon,” said the conservative political scientist Charles Murray, summarizing the appeal that Trump held for many of his loyalists.
After the shock of Trump’s victory in 2016, the denial and rationalizations kicked in fast. Just ride out the embarrassment for a few years, many thought, and then America would revert to something in the ballpark of sanity. But one of the overlooked portents of 2020 (many Democrats were too relieved to notice) was that the election was still extremely close. Trump received 74 million votes, nearly 47 percent of the electorate. That’s a huge amount of support, especially after such an ordeal of a presidency—the “very fine people on both sides,” the “perfect” phone call, the bleach, the daily OMG and WTF of it all. The populist nerves that Trump had jangled in 2016 remained very much aroused. Many of his voters’ grievances were unresolved. They clung to their murder weapon.
Trump has continued to test their loyalty. He hasn’t exactly enhanced his résumé since 2020, unless you count a second impeachment, several loser endorsements, and a bunch of indictments as selling points (some do, apparently: more medallions for his victimhood). January 6 posed the biggest hazard—the brutality of it, the fever of the multitudes, and Trump’s obvious pride in the whole furor. Even the GOP lawmakers who still vouched for Trump from their Capitol safe rooms seemed shaken.
“This is not who we are,” Representative Nancy Mace, the newly elected Republican of South Carolina, said of the deadly riot. “We’re better than this.” There was a lot of that: thoughts and prayers from freaked-out Americans. “Let me be very clear,” President-elect Joe Biden tried to reassure the country that day. “The scenes of chaos at the Capitol do not reflect a true America, do not represent who we are.”
One hoped that Biden was correct, that we were in fact not a nation of vandals, cranks, and insurrectionists. But then, on the very day the Capitol had been ransacked, 147 House and Senate Republicans voted not to certify Biden’s election. Kevin McCarthy, the House minority leader, skulked back to the ousted president a few weeks later, and the pucker-up parade to Mar-a-Lago was on. Large majorities of Republicans never stopped supporting Trump, and claim they never stopped believing that Biden stole the 2020 election and that Crooked Joe’s regime is abusing the legal system to persecute Trump out of the way.
Here we remain, amazingly enough, ready to do this all again. Trump might be the ultimate con man, but his essential nature has never been a mystery. Yet he appears to be gliding to his third straight Republican nomination and is running strong in a likely rematch with an unpopular incumbent. A durable coalition seems fully comfortable entrusting the White House to the guy who left behind a Capitol encircled with razor-wire fence and 25,000 National Guard troops protecting the federal government from his own supporters.
You can dismiss Trump voters all you want, but give them this: They’re every bit as American as any idealized vision of the place. If Trump wins in 2024, his detractors will have to reckon once again with the voters who got us here—to reconcile what it means to share a country with so many citizens who keep watching Trump spiral deeper into his moral void and still conclude, “Yes, that’s our guy.”
============================================================
49. A Cabinet officer likes private planes too much By Elaina Plott
In retrospect, this scandal almost seems quaint. Read More
48. The president praises the congressman who body-slammed a reporter By David French
In Trump’s view of masculinity, cheap shots replace bravery and hostility replaces honor. Read More
47. An overcompensating press secretary lies about crowd size By Megan Garber
In his inaugural appearance as White House press secretary, Sean Spicer set the tone for the next two years. Read More
46. Trump tells the Boy Scouts about a hot New York party By Yoni Appelbaum
“I was doing well, so I got invited to the party,” the president told thousands of teens at a jamboree. “I was very young.” Read More
45. A name-calling feud ends with the secretary of state’s ouster by tweet By Yara Bayoum.
It’s difficult to advance diplomatic goals when the president shows no qualms about publicly embracing American adversaries. Read More
44. The WikiLeaks president goes silent By George Packer
Julian Assange and Donald Trump share enemies—and they use similarly nihilistic tactics toward similarly antidemocratic ends. Read More
43. The nation loses its consoler in chief By James Fallows
In the wake of a tragedy, a president must act as the leader of supporters and critics alike. Trump has proved incapable of this. Read More
42. The first president to complain about an election he won By David Graham
The past two years have shown that Trump has no special affection for the democratic process. Read More
41. Trump waits 19 months to pick his science adviser By Ed Yong
In this administration, empiricism is inconvenient and expertise unnecessary. Read More
40. The president’s most trusted adviser is his own gut By Sarah Zhang
The president’s glandular instinct has become a substitute for all expertise and all nuance. Read More
39. A White House economist creates facts for the president By Tom Nichols
In Trump’s world, reality is negotiable. Read More
38. Trump holds a top secret confab on the Mar-a-Lago dining terrace By Ian Bogost
The president has repeatedly proved himself a hypocrite when it comes to information security. But what about her emails? Read More
37. The president just wants to go home By Vauhini Vara
Trump has visited fewer foreign countries than his predecessors, as American influence abroad diminishes. Read More
36. Trump threatens to strip security clearances from his critics By David Frum
The administration may have broken precedent in more than one way. Read More
35. Mueller’s “witch hunt” is good at finding witches By Ciara Torres-Spelliscy
The indictments keep coming, no matter what Trump says. Read More
34. Trump leads the country to the longest government shutdown in American history By Saahil Desai
And it isn’t just the longest—it’s different in another meaningful way. Read More
33. The chief justice of the United States corrects the president By Scott Stossel
The rare rebuke from John Roberts shows that he fears for the viability of our political system. Read More
32. Trump disseminates Soviet propaganda By Kori Schake
Seriously, though. Read More
31. The White House punishes a CNN reporter for asking questions By Emily Bell
What started as a theatrical rivalry is now actively putting press freedom in jeopardy. Read More
30. The buck stops over there By Kathy Gilsinan
The president loves splashy displays of military might. But when something goes wrong, he blames his generals. Read More
29. The president tries to kick transgender service members out of the military By Matt Thompson
Do impulsive Twitter messages from the president count as formal policy action? Read More
28. Trump tweets the wisdom of Mussolini By Krishnadev Calamur
“I know who said it,” he insisted. “But what difference does it make?” Read More
27. Turkish agents assault protesters near the White House By Don Peck
And Trump stayed silent. Read More
26. Trump helps the Saudis cover up a murder By Lyse Doucet
The president made it very clear what really matters to him. Read More
25. “We’re gonna have the cleanest air” By Robinson Meyer
In withdrawing the United States from the Paris Agreement, an indoor man rewrote the future of the Earth’s climate. Read More
24. The president can’t stop talking about carnage By Rebecca J. Rosen
Donald Trump’s grim view of the world was obvious from the day he was inaugurated. Read More
23. America gets a first daughter By Caitlin Flanagan
That’s not really a thing. Read More
22. The UN General Assembly laughs at the president By Rachel Donadio
And American allies are laughing at the whole country. Read More
21. Rain stops Trump from honoring the dead By Eliot A. Cohen
Most presidents have visited and spoken at Arlington National Cemetery on Veterans Day. Not Trump. Read More
20. The president learns about separation of powers By Russell Berman
And he does not like it. Read More
18. The president lies constantly By Angie Drobnic Holan
Americans have never seen this level of truth-bending come out of the Oval Office. Read More
17. Trump threatens to press his “nuclear button” By Uri Friedman
Then he tried to persuade North Korea’s dictator to abandon his weapons with a faux movie trailer. Read More
16. Public humiliation comes for everyone in the White House By Alex Wagner
James Mattis’s departure was a turning point. Read More
15. The CIA dead become a TV prop By Vernon Loeb
The president’s strained relationship with the intelligence community goes back to his visit to Langley just a day after his inauguration. Read More
14. You know you’re in a constitutional crisis when… By Quinta Jurecic
The health of the republic may seem imperiled, but this is in many ways a slow-moving catastrophe. Read More
13. Trump mocks Christine Blasey Ford to a cheering crowd By McKay Coppins
He’s a master of reading a room—and he knows exactly how to use cultural context as a provocation. Read More
12. A new term enters the presidential lexicon: “shithole countries” By Ibram X. Kendi
In insulting certain countries, Trump revealed the hierarchy he imposes on the world. Read More
11. Trump throws paper towels at Puerto Ricans By Vann R. Newkirk II
That really happened. Read More
10. “I have the absolute right to pardon myself” By Garrett Epps
Trump’s claim goes way beyond Nixon’s “I’m not a crook.” Read More
9. Covfefe By Adrienne LaFrance
In the annals of revelatory Trump tweets, this one’s the ultimate. Read More
8. The president calls his porn-star ex-paramour “horseface” By Sophie Gilbert
No other commander-in-chief has offered such direct, unfiltered access to his psyche. Read More
7. Trump picks the wrong countries for his travel ban By Hannah Giorgis
The president’s stated purpose was to keep terrorists out, but his plan has all kinds of problems. Read More
6. Trump declares war on black athletes By Jemele Hill
Trump is the only president in recent memory to attack players for their politics. Read More
5. James Comey is fired By Benjamin Wittes
May 9, 2017, could turn out to be the most consequential day in the history of this presidency. Read More
4. Putin and Trump talk without chaperones By Franklin Foer
What did Donald Trump say to Vladimir Putin when no one else could hear them? Read More
3. The president still hasn’t released his tax returns By Annie Lowrey
He also seems to be making a lot of money outside the presidency. Read More
2. “Very fine people on both sides” By Adam Serwer
Trump’s response to Charlottesville reveals the core of his philosophy. Read More
1. Children are taken from their parents and incarcerated By Ashley Fetters
To separate children from their parents is an offense against nature and civilized society. Read More